I’ve really got to get my shit together. I’ve got a bunch of loops to close, and I need to clear a bunch of fluffy, high-concept horsecrap off my desk to make room for meatier stuff next month. Stuff like time tension clock pool complications and how to unsuck searching and perception so it’s actually a game and some adventure-design stuff too.
Today, I want to wrap up the whole comprehensive approach to challenge design in fantasy adventure tabletop roleplaying games thing that I’ve inexplicably titled The Third Heat. I want to, but I can’t. I need to take a detour before I can finish it. That said, I will be finishing it this week.
You see, as I’ve been pissing and moaning about what is and is not gameplay by strict, academic standards and dumping on open-ended creativity challenges and naked dice rolling, some people have asked about something I haven’t discussed and really didn’t intend to. But they’ve made good enough points that I kind of have to.
So…
Does character build choice count as gameplay? It’s a good question, but the answer is complicated and disappointing.
With that sales pitch, let’s get to it…
Is Character Buildery Gameplay?
The question today is whether players building their characters cleverly and strategically meet my overly demanding but also increasingly vague definition of gameplay and, especially, does it count enough to be considered a fourth heat in gameplay challenge construction. Whatever the hell that means.
I am not going to rehash all my caveats about how gameplay is an actual word with an actual meaning, but that meaning is descriptive rather than prescriptive and that it’s qualitative, but none of that means you can just make up your own meaning and how I’m relying on the work of people smarter than me to define it. That all still stands.
The first two parts of this little essay series are still there. Go review them if you have to.
The Third Heat (Part I): Open-Ended Creativity Challenges Aren’t Bad, They’re Brittle
The Third Heat (Part II): Naked Die Rolling Just Isn’t Right
My grand thesis is that, for something to count as gameplay, it has to ask something of the player, and it has to be a fair ask. Basically, if you want to say you’re playing a game, you have to make consequential choices, forming and executing a strategic plan, or drawing a logical conclusion from a pattern of facts and clues. Mostly, I’ve focused on consequential choices, but when I get around to the actual third heat, I’ll have more to say about plans and conclusions and how they’re not just blank-page creative lateral thinking.
Some of my readers have pointed out that character building involves a lot of consequential choices and strategic plans. By choosing one skill over another, you’re determining what approaches you’ll even have access to, and the feats, talents, and abilities you pick can affect your odds of success pretty drastically. Your character creation choices can also provide bonus-granting resources you can use to juice checks that would otherwise be naked die rolls. You might even walk into open-ended creativity challenges with assets and tools that provide enough of a starting point that you’re not just trying to creative a solution out of the ether by overcoming functional fixedness or whatever.
If you have made any of those points, I hereby officially recognize you as Not a Complete Asshat, and I even award you a coveted Angry Cookie. Moreover, if you ever meet me at a convention or event, you may ask for one complimentary Pat On The Head With Accompanying Verbal Acknowledgment That You Did a Good Job.
I am actually being serious here. About all of it. Those are actually good points. But are they good enough to qualify character buildery as a fourth heat in gameplay challenge design?
Unfortunately, the answer is, “kinda sorta but not really.” Character buildery has its place in the game and it’s actually doing more for gameplay than either open-ended creativity challenges or naked die rolls. The problem is that, for several reasons I’m going to expound upon, and one reason I can’t really expound upon, it’s not doing enough in terms of the challenge part of gameplay to affect how you need to build challenges for your game.
And, actually, that’s not really about character buildery, but rather about the specific nature of tabletop roleplaying games as a medium.
Hedging My Bet on Character Buildery as System Design
As I alluded, there’s part of this discussion that’s just hard to, you know, discuss. Tabletop roleplaying games represent a pretty broad medium, and character buildery is something that some systems make a giant thing out of while others barely do anything with. In some systems, your build choices drastically affect how you play your character. Mechanically, I mean. This is all about actual gameplay mechanics. In other systems, the build choices are mostly cosmetic and don’t affect the gameplay much at all. Worse yet, lots of games seem like they make a big thing about character buildery, but none of it is actually very consequential from a gameplay standpoint.
For reasons I’ve explained to death, I tend to use the current edition of one of the world’s roleplaying games as my baseline for discussing game design. It’s the game I run the most, it’s the game most of my readers are running, and it’s the game almost every gamer has at least passed through on their way to their game du jour of today. It’s also the game almost every other game is built on, either by deliberate adaptation, accidental absorption, or deliberate rejection.
I also use fantasy adventure as my baseline for the same reasons.
Character buildery is one of those things that’s very hard to discuss comprehensively across the whole spectrum of tabletop roleplaying gaming, but I don’t think I actually have to. I think, by the end, you’ll see that, no matter how good and consequential the character buildery might be in whatever system you want to discuss, the nature of the medium itself makes it hard to rely on as a component of gameplay challenge construction. That is, except for one weird little x-factor that I hope I don’t forget to discuss when it becomes relevant.
Actually, let me just throw it in here right now so I don’t forget to toss it out and then move on like it’s nothing, leaving all of you demanding an explanation I won’t provide until the next time I’m so behind in my writing that I start looking for fluffy, high-concept horsecrap I can answer with one short essay that turns into four.
So, you know, probably next week.
The one system-level thing that can change how much character buildery affects gameplay challenge construction, kind of, is whether the system has way too many approach-generating or approach-impacting skills. What the hell does that mean? I’m referring here to skills that open up strategies and approaches that wouldn’t otherwise be available without them. Lockpicking, for example, is approach-generating. Without it, you just can’t bypass locks non-destructively without a key. Intimidation is closer to an approaching-impacting skill. Anyone can make a threat, but the odds of it having a mechanical impact in most systems are generally low enough without the skill, and the stakes of failing are usually so high that, without the skill, most players don’t want to try throwing their weight around.
If a system has way too many approach-generating skills, traits, and abilities, its character buildery might just be consequential enough to count as a fourth heat.
Otherwise, character buildery just ain’t that big a deal.
To explain why, we have to talk about video games.
Oh, Look, Angry Is Talking Video Games Again
To really think through this whole is character buildery consequential enough to count as gameplay question, we need to look at a medium where it usually definitely often sometimes is. That medium is video games.
Of course, it shouldn’t surprise you that I’m looking for answers in video games. When you’re talking game design, you really only have four choices: roleplaying games, video games, board games, and sports. Roleplaying games are what we’re trying to solve, so they don’t have the answer; board games are usually too constrained and abstractly mechanical to give us an answer, and sports give most gamers heart attacks because we’re not exactly sporty people as a community, so video games are all that’s left.
Also, for those of you with Angry Talks Video Games Bingo Cards, you can tick off Dark Souls, Bloodborne, and Hollow Knight right now. No surprises there. You won’t see any Metroid or Zelda though. Sorry about that.
Anyway…
There are lots of video games, franchises, and genres that feature character buildery as a core part of the experience, but, the way I see it, which is the correct way, you can lump them all into three broad groups: build mastery, build swappery, and path choosery.
Let’s look at each in turn, then see where tabletop roleplaying games should fit into this mess.
… and why they don’t.
Build Mastery: Dance With Who You Brought With You
Lots of skill-based and strategy-based games that have a lot of consequential character buildery feature what I’m calling build mastery. Either you choose a build at the start of the game, or else you make choices throughout the game to select and then deepen your commitment to a particular build. Maybe you choose your armor-and-weapon set, maybe you pick an archetype, maybe you commit to one of three skill trees… it doesn’t matter.
The key is that the builds are different enough to affect how you play the game and that the challenge comes from mastering your build and using it to win. Some of the game’s challenges will suit your build very well. They’ll be pushovers. Others, though, won’t. Those are the challenges that will test your mastery because you’ll have to win even though your build isn’t the best tool for the job.
The original Dark Souls and Bloodborne are really strong examples of build mastery design, and I would even argue that Elden Ring fits here. I know some of you are going to object, and I have an answer, so just hold on. I’ll get to it.
Note that some team-based strategy games and tactical roleplaying games fall into this category as well. Because party or squad composition is the equivalent of a build. If the game lets you choose a roster of characters or build the characters how you like, but then expects you to play primarily with that party against all the challenges, that’s a kind of build mastery. It’s kind of hard to come up with recent examples though, because lots of party-based games these days let you easily swap your roster. Which means they aren’t really about mastering your build to win every challenge, but rather, they’re about…
Build Swappery: Bring the Right Tool for Every Job
It’s become increasingly common in skill-based games that feature consequential character buildery to let the player swap out their build on the fly. And I’m not talking about little tweaks here, like a trinket that reduces fire damage or increases charge attacks, but things that actually drastically change the gameplay. That’s what build swappery is. You have a build, it’s consequential, but the game lets you change it drastically to respond to the challenges you face.
The most obvious example right now is the second best game in the Hollow Knight franchise, Silksong. Through equippable trinkets, subweapons, and weapon movesets, you can completely change the way the character plays to deal with specific bosses or challenges. Any party-based or squad-based game that lets you swap your roster for different missions or fights also counts because, in party-based games, your roster is your build. You get that right.
Whereas the challenge in build mastery games is to master your build well enough to beat any challenge with it, in build swappery games, you’re expected to recognize when a different loadout can provide a cleaner, more efficient win rather than smashing every round encounter with your square build.
Which brings me to the complicating factor in this whole analysis…
Build Inertia and Design Intent: Because Buildery is a Spectrum
Blah blah blah standard reminder blah blah qualitative definition blah descriptive not prescriptive blah blahdy blah.
Any game that lets you pick anything about your character technically has character buildery, right? But that doesn’t mean character buildery is a key facet of the gameplay and certainly doesn’t make it a consequential part of the challenge design. If the build differences are small and just tweak the gameplay a bit, it ain’t right to say character buildery is part of the challenge gameplay. It’s something players can use for leaning into preferences or handicapping or for personal expression or to play out a particular fantasy. Those are elements of gameplay, but they aren’t gameplay, and they aren’t challenge.
You get that, right?
I bring that up for two reasons. First, because people took my previous essays to mean that creative problem solving and dice-rolling don’t have places in the gameplay. They totally, absolutely do. So does character building. Second, because this character buildery stuff can’t be so neatly categorized as I’m making it sound.
This character buildery crap never exists in any kind of pure form. For example, folks will rightly point out that Dark Souls and Bloodborne and especially Elden Ring not only allow you to do some build swappery, they actually expect some. That’s true. In fact, let me argue against myself here just to show you I’m not afraid of a fight. When I play Silksong, I don’t swap my build but ever. I occasionally change a subweapon; I’ll sometimes equip a trinket to mitigate a specific boss attack, but in pretty much every fight, I’m Hunter’s Crest and Thread Storm. I don’t build swap. I just don’t. It ain’t a thing I enjoy. Whatever the game starts me with, for the most part, I’ll finish with it. I’ve never played Bloodborne with anything other than the whippy cane or the toothy cleaver. Actually, I prefer the Saw Spear, but that’s so close to a starting weapon that it counts.
It’s pretty rare for a game to either lock you into one build forever or to force you to change your build for every fight, so player preference will always be a factor, but you can still classify games as mostly build mastery or mostly build swappery. It’s down to designer expectation. How is the game made?
For example, there’s this thing I’m gonna call build inertia. It’s basically about how much effort it takes to change a build. Maybe build commitment is a better term. How likely is the player to commit to a build? In the Soulsborne games, changing builds late in the game can be a massive pain in the ass. Weapon upgrades are a big part of how effective your weapons are, and powerful weapons found in the world often have ridiculous stat requirements. If you’ve sunk all your upgrades and stat points into the build you’ve got now, swapping is onerous. It’s doable. Upgrade materials are plentiful enough to make it possible and, if you’re willing to check a wiki or you’re on a second playthrough, you can plan your stats in advance for a late-game weapon. Or even rush to that weapon out of the gate if you’ve gitted gud enuff. Even so, that’s not the same as on-the-fly swapping, though in games where you can maintain, say, two or three good loadouts and hot-swap them, you’re getting into the hazy realm between build mastery and build swappery.
Games that are heavily skill-based can also add a lot of build inertia. One of the reasons I stick with the Hunter’s Crest in Silksong is that I got comfortable with it. It’s the default moveset, and you’re several hours in before you discover you can even change movesets. My muscle memory is all for the Hunter’s Crest. Swapping never felt comfortable.
You can take everything I’ve said and substitute in squad makeup or party roster for tactical games and for party-based roleplaying games. Remember those older party-based RPGs in which your benched party members didn’t advance? That’s build inertia. You were better off picking your favorite party and sticking with it. Meanwhile, RPGs with ensemble casts that make switching quick and easy and penalty-free are basically build swappery. And somewhere in between are the games where there’s build inertia, but a few hours of grinding and some equipment management can let you at least choose a new favorite party to commit to for the rest of the game.
So, yeah, there’s a spectrum, and there are preferences, but there’s also how the game is designed, and none of it’s pure. Most games mix approaches. It ain’t clean. This ain’t about arguing what games go where. Instead, it’s about analyzing whether the consequential character buildery touches gameplay in its special place enough to count as a fourth heat.
Speaking of which, there’s a third type of consequential character buildery yet.
Path Choosery: The Build Becomes the Way
Both build mastery and build swappery are about how character buildery affects the way players engage with the game’s challenges. The challenges themselves don’t really change. Every player faces basically the same challenges, fights, bosses, missions, and quests, and they mostly face them the same way. Each player’s build just changes what execution looks like.
Some games, though, do change the challenges you face based on the build you choose, though there’s an important nuance to this that I’ll get to. Consider immersive sims and many action and adventure roleplaying games. Think Deus Ex, Prey, Fallout, The Outer Worlds, and even Baldur’s Gate and Divinity: Original Sin.
Note that these are all things we’d call proper roleplaying games, right?
Now, some of the challenges don’t change regardless of build. There are build mastery and build swappery elements in all of those games, but the defining feature of path choosery games is that your build has a lot to say about what path you take through the game and what encounters you’ll even have.
In a path choosery game, you often pick a skillset that defines what approaches are even open to you, right? If you spec for infiltration, you can hack computers and pick locks, which means you’ll have access to paths and information other players don’t. If you spec for interaction, you might be able to talk your way into places or access missions unavailable to other players. That’s what I mean by picking your path through the game.
But even challenges common to all paths may not actually be the same challenge. This is where I have to make a fine point. Imagine a game lets you pick between stealth assassinating and guns-blazey fighting. Now there are some thugs in an alley you have to get through. You could argue that, technically, it’s the same encounter and that the challenge has changed, but you’d be wrong in every practical way. The stealth player and the combat player may be dealing with the same surface obstacle in the same location, but they are not playing the same game. They are literally facing completely different gameplay challenges.
Game designers know this, and you know they know it if you’ve ever played a game where the designers didn’t realize that every arena had to be designed twice: once for guns-blazing combat and once for sneaky stealth ganking. Hell, Game Masters know it too. Can you honestly say that the encounter in which the party sneaks past the goblins and the one where they fight the goblins are the same encounter just because it’s the same map and the same stat blocks?
That’s what makes path choosery what it is. The player isn’t making decisions that affect how the game’s unchanging challenges play, they’re literally picking what game they want to play. They’re picking what encounters they want to have. This is key because, when we’re talking about challenge design, path choosery character buildery doesn’t mean you build one challenge and let the players’ builds affect the difficulty, but rather, it means you’re building challenges for each build and then disguising them as one challenge.
Whither Tabletop Roleplaying Games
Now that we all understand the three broad approaches to making character buildery a part of the gameplay, and specifically, a part of challenge design, we can try to figure out where tabletop roleplaying games fall. Except we don’t, because the answer is probably pretty obvious. Except the obvious answer isn’t the only correct answer, and it also doesn’t help us nearly as much as you might think.
Let’s take this one step at a time…
First, we can take build swappery off the table… top roleplaying game. By their nature, tabletop roleplaying games don’t really do build swappery. I’m not saying you can’t swap loadouts easily, and I concede that Vanician spellcasting is basically magical build swappery, but we have to be really precise here about what it means to call build swappery a core part of the challenge gameplay. Most characters really can’t completely change their builds in ways that fundamentally impact how they approach challenges. Even games that let you retrain don’t usually let you completely reinvent your character on the fly. At best, it’s more like picking a new build mastery to build master.
By the way, I don’t think retraining should exist in tabletop roleplaying games. I understand why retraining now appears in games, but I think it’s a bad choice and that it undermines key conceits of tabletop roleplaying games. It’s also just dumb.
But even if you could reinvent your tabletop roleplaying game character on the fly whenever you wanted, you still wouldn’t get to true build swappery because, at its heart, it’s about facing challenges, failing, tweaking your build, and trying again. You need an experimentation-feedback-swapout gameplay cycle to truly build swappery. Tabletop roleplaying games don’t feature a lot of respawning to try failed challenges again.
So, that covers build swappery. Before I move on to the obvious answer you’re already screaming, I want to recognize that build mastery actually features heavily in many tabletop roleplaying games. Especially fantasy adventure roleplaying games. Especially the current edition of one of the world’s roleplaying games. The entire combat engine in Dungeons & Dragons and the two-thirds of character buildery that’s all about combat are entirely about build mastery. That’s so simple and obvious, I’m not even going to argue the point. I’m just going to point at it and say, “Duh!”
The problem is that you don’t have to care about that. The one thing you don’t need help with is designing combats in systems like D&D. It’s the easiest thing in the world. The system makes pretty much anything you throw at the players into a good fight as long as the math works. Pick some monsters, draw a map, run the numbers so it’s not an easy-breezy cakewalk or a super-deadly slaughter, and you’re fine.
All right, all right… Don’t get your panties in a craw. I’m being snarky. There is an art to making good combat encounters, and I’ll never say otherwise. But it’s not the same problem as, “How do I build an actual gameplay challenge out of a locked door or a belligerent bouncer?” That’s what we’re looking at here.
So we can ignore build mastery. Yes, it’s there, and yes, it matters, but it’s handled already. It is gameplay, but it’s not gameplay you need to sweat when you design an adventure or encounter. The system’s got you.
Which brings us to the obvious one. Obviously, character buildery is consequential gameplay because path choosery. Except that path choosery isn’t gameplay in any way that matters. And, even if it was, tabletop roleplaying games ruin it.
Path Choosery Isn’t Actually Gameplay Enough to Count
There are basically two sides to the whole path choosery character buildery, right?
First, you’ve got this idea that, by picking a build, you’re picking the approaches that are available to you during gameplay, right? Spec lockpicking and you can pick locks, spec interacting, you can schmooze bouncers, and so on. But all that’s doing is opening up possibilities for naked die rolling, and we already talked about how picking which naked die roll to make isn’t gameplay. Remember the door you can pick or break down? That’s not really gameplay in any consequential way.
Second, though, there’s the idea that path choosery is about picking different challenges, right? If you’ve specced for stealth, you can sneak past the goblins instead of fighting them. That is definitely true. Kind of. But does that make the character buildery into gameplay? Well, yes, a little bit, but not enough because the actual gameplay comes from you actually executing the sneak. Building a character that can sneak isn’t playing a game; it’s choosing to be allowed to play a sneaking game later. The gameplay is the sneaking game itself.
As an adventure designer, this path choosery shit doesn’t actually help you build gameplay, it just expands the list of gameplays you have to build. You still have to build a sneaking challenge that counts as actual gameplay. One that isn’t an open-ended creativity challenge and isn’t a naked die roll.
Meanwhile, the character buildery has already done everything it’s going to do. The moment the player made the choice to spec into stealth, they opened up the stealth approach, and that’s all they did. Which, actually, is a problem with path choosery-type character buildery in general. Yeah, building the character is gameplay, but it’s gameplay that’s done once the character is built unless you can find a way to build an execution challenge around it. Which, frankly, you should be doing anyway.
As an adventure writer, you should be including various kinds of encounters and encounters that allow for multiple approaches by default. You shouldn’t need the fact that builds exist to tell you that open-ended roleplaying games need to accommodate multiple approaches. Besides, if you ever leave out an approach, the game will still handle it. First, because there are rules for handling everything that exists on the character sheet, and second, because there’s a Game Master with a set of tools for handling such things.
If you design the goblins as a combat encounter, but the players decide to sneak past them, the Game Master will decide if that’s possible and adjudicate the actions and make it happen, cap’n. That’s what Game Masters do.
Which is the first way in which the nature of tabletop roleplaying games ruins the whole path choosery thing.
It’s like this…
Path choosery character building does four things: it lets the player set gameplay preferences, it lets players express their creativity, it lets the player choose a particular fantasy to fulfill, and it makes repeated playthroughs more interesting and varied. Actually, you could also argue that it also provides a foundation for community engagement about the game. Discussing games, watching streams, and checking fan wikis are all a lot more fun if the game gives a different experience to every player.
Creative expression and fantasy are great, and they totally belong in tabletop roleplaying games, but they emerge naturally from being allowed to create a character and from the open-ended gameplay. When I’m trying to decide how to make a locked door into actual gameplay, I ain’t worrying about them. Repeated playthroughs and community engagement aren’t factors that tabletop roleplaying games have to care about. So now, it’s just down to gameplay preferences, right? But because of the nature of roleplaying games, the players can express and adjust their preferences constantly through play. If they mostly prefer talking through the game, they can do that. Meanwhile, I, as an adventure writer, don’t need to care because I understand interaction is one of the core gameplay engagements, so it’s always a possibility I build into my adventures.
So the build choice matters, but not in any way I care about when I’m creating gameplay challenges, and if the game didn’t include character builds at all, the players would still be able to pick their approaches and express their preferences.
But the nature of tabletop roleplaying games isn’t done undermining character buildery yet. You see, tabletop roleplaying games are group endeavors. It isn’t just one player picking one build. You have a mix of five players with five builds and therefore five sets of gameplay preferences. Which means you might as well not have any builds at all. Why? Because, for all practical purposes, you’re going to be satisfying most of the common gameplay preferences most of the time anyway. You’re going to need some interaction for the interactive players, you’re always going to have a stealthy player, you’re going to fill the game with some action, include a few puzzles for the players who like that kind of thing, and you don’t even need to look at the character sheets to know that.
Meanwhile, you can also rest assured that, unless your game has way too many skills, which it should, the players are going to cover everything. They just naturally do. Especially if you let the group talk before they create characters. They work out who’s got lockpicking covered and who will do the healing and who can hunt for food. That’s how players be.
Effectively and practically, what that means is that every party is pretty much coming to the table with a Batman build. Every approach will be available through someone, every path will be viable, and you will have to build a mix of challenges to give the players a little variety.
Because of how tabletop roleplaying games work, the build is always the same. You will have one party who has specced in pretty much everything.
So, is character building gameplay?
Yes. It’s just not gameplay in any way that helps you build a game in the slightest.
Sorry.

Makes sense to me, thanks.
I think the main issue with build swapping in TTRPGs is that it’s typically tedious. Like, yeah, if the players and you are okay with swapping characters after session one, that’s fine. But, swapping after the character has had ten levels? Yeah no, unless the player really absolutely despises their character, I’m going to say no 95% of the time. Unless it’s a minor change like “my character has never used this spell once, but our system doesn’t allow spell swapping, can I pick a different spell?” And for that I’m like, sure, but I honestly am thinking about whether I should allow that now. I kind of like the feeling of a spell that “feels useless now” to somehow become useful once the player actually tries to use it.
I think I am going to allow spell swapping like that less often now.
It seems like this would only be true if you didn’t know your party (e.g., if you’re designing for distribution, or for a Con one-shot, etc.). If you know the build of your party would that help with challenge design? If nobody has opted for the public speaking/persuasion/diplomatic “build”, could you focus more on the challenges for deception, intimidation, mind control, etc.?
Not all adventure writers know who will be playing. Not all Game Masters know. Game Masters can write adventures not knowing what characters the players are going to bring even for a regular game among friends. And it’s best if you, when you’re wearing your adventure design hat, don’t think too hard about the party anyway, otherwise you just end up with things the players can throw naked die rolls at. This is precisely the problem we’re trying to solve. “I know someone has intimidation, so I’ll design a guard that can be intimidated.” Great. Now you’re just designing for naked dice rolls. Le sigh.
I see your point, though I was thinking more the opposite (I know they have an intimidator, so I’ll throw something at them that’s hard to intimidate as a challenge), but I figure that’s just another iteration of the same problem?
You should build something that is afraid of something and courageous of something else, then there is gameplay. How will they find out? A battled scared 2 meter tall orc might not be easily intimidated by the fear of physical pain, but belt with symbols of good fortune might show it might be scared of spells or superstitions.
It is, for actual gameplay you should build the guard with battle scars and symbols of good fortune and protection against ill desires. In this case if the intimidation uses fear of spells, or superstitious believes you reward with easier test, if thei timidation is “otherwise I hurt you” penalize the player. Then it becomes gameplay, same skill yet the decision will make it more likely or not of success or failure.
I think the point here is that when one is trying to design gameplay challenges for a TTRPG, it is usually fruitless to design challenges for the gameplay that is character buildery. Understanding the particular build of the party you are designing for, or the general parameters of character buildery in the system you are designing for, will (probably) be useful when designing a good gameplay challenge, but those buildery decisions will not be the gameplay itself. If, for example, you want to design an adventure for your home table party that is built towards deception and not persuasion, you can do that by building good deception challenges. But those challenges will be the gameplay, not the choices the group made to build for deception in the first place.
To summarize my understanding of Angry’s slow burning thesis: the thing that you need to build good gameplay challenges is the mysterious “third heat” (coming soon!). It’s not the first heat, it’s not the second heat, and it’s not the fourth heat. The first and the second aren’t *really* gameplay, and the fourth you can’t design for in TTRPGs (although you can in video games).
Extending this line of thought with a hypothetical, imagine a TTRPG adventure that *was* primarily designed around the gameplay of character buildery. What might that look like?
1) The players would need to have some idea about what type of obstacles their characters might face. (Informed decisions)
2) The players would choose their approach(es) to the anticipated obstacles by selecting character build options. (Meaningful choices)
3) The characters would encounter the challenges and succeed or fail based on those character build choices and some degree of chance. The characters have a reasonable chance of success and failure. It should be possible to succeed with a good build, and it should be possible to fail with a bad build. (Impactful choices)
5) If the characters fail, the players can attempt a new approach by changing their character builds. (gameplay loop)
In the most extreme version of this, the players make no decisions, or no “true gameplay” decisions, outside of character building. The characters are like wind-up toys that you craft and then set loose in the dungeon. The “play” of the adventure is basically the players and GM running a simulation, naked die rolls and obvious optimization choices, to find out what happens. A whole session could be considered one very long and elaborate action resolution. And it’s not until the very end, when the team has either won the adventure or failed hopelessly that the GM loops back to all the players to ask “What do you do?” The answer to which is tinker with our character builds and try again.
Now, supposedly, some old school games were designed with this play loop in mind, or at least admit it. Curiously, the BX and OSR style games that seem suited to this have much fewer character build options, and higher chance variability, than say the current edition of one of the world’s roleplaying games. I think in order to make character buildery a core gameplay challenge mode, you do have to shorten the timescale of the loop between character building and resolving the outcome of those build choices. This might also looked like a Tavern Simulator style game where each player had a stable of characters (of different classes and builds) and assembling the team based on the adventure of the jour is part of the game (aka Swappery). Overall, while I find these types of play are fun, I think it tends toward puzzles and simulation, taking the player out of the roleplaying mindset of “What would I do if I were this person in this world?”
Interesting. From a player perspective, I always felt like the character buildery was a part of the gameplay, specifically in the “what would I do if I were this person in this world” context. The character buildery is where I become “this person”, so it begins the immersion process that feeds that experience. And mechanically, I feel like it is as much a part of the gameplay (as a player) as building a deck is in M:TG. I can see where the distinction carries weight from the design perspective, but all the gameplay endorphins as a player sure feel like they are triggered when I’m figuring out whether my wizard is spraying glamor or spitting fireballs.
Yeah, that’s an interesting perspective and I realize I haven’t really had a chance to “get into a character” as a player in a while. I think giving people the good brain chemicals from character building is in most ways down to system design, and adventure design can at most try to ride those coattails.
But if a system wants to give players that gameplay feels from character buildery, the payoff has to come during an adventure, right? So at least some share of adventures need to include that in their design goals. If the game system wants the players to choose between glamour and fireballs (and for that choice to be meaningful in overcoming challenges) then at some point there should a situation where you get to glamour the unfireballable demon and also a situation of frisson when you run up against the unglamourous zombies.
In my ideal of D&D, the system gives a broad and rich enough constellation of these character trade-offs in quasi “balanced” manner that adventure designers can follow a mostly party-build agnostic method, and the result should be that maybe 10% of the time the party has an ace that short circuits the intended gameplay, 10% of the time they are totally stymied and need to regroup, and 80% of the time its standard gameplay. Personally, as a player, it deflates my sense of character buildery accomplishment if I think that GM is deliberately throwing me a softball, or doing a Lucy ball yoink. It feels better if the boons and banes of my build choices show up “naturally“.
If you did that you’d be playing 3rd edition. Ba dum tiss.
This makes me unsatisfied with the mechanical nature of skills (in 5Eish) in general. If it’s a facet that you invest at character creation, it progresses for the rest of the character’s career without any further decisions. And the better you are at something, the more it becomes a push-button solution. And as you point out, the specialization across the party means that someone will be pretty good at anything. Why would a Rogue with a +15 to Persuasion skill ever not attempt a naked roll as an opening gambit?
I can build a good challenge where the players must find key pieces of information to blackmail members of the city council. Maybe part of that is the GM not allowing a dice roll to persuade a council member until they have proof he is skimming from the treasury. That seems contrived if I always have to create reasons why skill use through naked rolls won’t work, but we could justify that for major set pieces (the un-lockpickable runic door until you find the four pieces of enchanted jade). Then the players must engage with the game where it matters most and naked die rolls are limited to approaches that provide minor utility or shortcuts or increase the odds of success of an approach when paired with other aspects of gameplay challenges (3 pieces of evidence is an instant success but 1 piece of evidence and a good roll convinces the council member to fall in line).
Thank you! This was illuminating,… even if it doesn’t actually help build games hahaha
What about life path character generation systems, like in Traveller, where you can actually die during character generation? Is that actual game play?
It’s usually just naked dice rolling. It’s also… well… at this point, I won’t call it terrible because I sense it’s one of those cult things that is just considered “part of the fun.” Objectively speaking, it’s awful game design, but it has become a sort of “so bad it’s good” thing for lots of people.
I think of the Traveller character generation as a mini-game, which is very distinct form the core gameplay. Once your character completes their final term and musters out to become a Traveller, that’s when the real game starts. Everything before that is mostly random dice with a few choices thrown in.
Sure, you can try to game the generation process to try to ‘win’ and get a PC with lots of skills and benefits. E.g. Attempting a career that you’re less likely to survive, but have a high chance of promotion if you do.
But ultimately Traveller character generation doesn’t feel like roleplaying. It feels more like gambling.
Will my character survive another term?
Will my character suffer the effects of aging?
Just my two cents.
In the latest version you can make some rather significant choices to improve your odds of getting specific skills or even ships or gear, or you can play it very safe. Most of the events have a choice to risk a negative outcome for a benefit, rather like gameplay And there are things like the Connection rule, where you get a free skill level for creating a tie with another character.
It is more like gameplay than the original, certainly. You can still die during character creation, but it’s very difficult to do so.
The charm of the whole thing is in dealing with what the system gives you when it wasn’t exactly what you or your character had planned. Just like real life.
You didn’t mention Card Games. I’d assume you just lumped them in with Board Games, which is OK. But as I think about these games, they fall into a spectrum… Most have no “pre-game” i.e. Planning / Building phase – so games like Poker, Monopoly – you just set up the board / deal the cards, and immediately start the game-play loop. But games like Risk, 500, Bridge and Magic the Gathering – they all have some kind of Planning / Bidding / Building phase, where a player (or pair of players) has a pre-game phase, where they can try and strategically build out what their opening strategy might be, before the core game loop begins. For example in Risk you get to shape what your strategy is right from placing your armies on the board; in 500 or Bridge you get random cards but your bidding sets up whether you’re going offense or defense and gives you clues on how to play the actual game once the bid is settled; in MtG you build your own deck constrained only by what cards you’ve got available. I think these kinds of games can also help us think about the “pre-game” of TTRPGs – for some players, it’s a big deal (think 3.5e D&D), for other’s, they just want to get into the core game-play loop i.e. play the damn game. As a DM, we just need to understand that results may vary, and if a player likes the pre-game more than the game, then maybe think about how to account for that…
I may not be in the right mindset for this, but is this even a debate? If it constitutes any kind of play, you’re just playing with yourself. And a group of people all playing with themselves at the same table, well that’s a circle-jerk.
–
As for path choosery, I would reflect that in video games, it’s mainly just about numbers go up, and if you accrue 10 bad boy points you get to punch the snarky reporter when the flashing indicator shows up, otherwise you just say sorry and have an awkward exit or something.
If we had anything like that in ttrpgs, well the Mountain doesn’t need to roll intimidate, because he’s the Mountain, kind of thing. Which I could certainly foresee plenty of potential pitfalls with, but at the same time, when was the last time your character’s height, weight or looks mattered in game?
In D&D, you just take the intimidating trait or whatever and that’s that, but there isn’t like consequences derived from your build. Like the short thief has to be trained in acrobatics to make it up to the ledge but the tall muscular thief can just pull himself up, and when the ceiling gets lower the short thief just runs on like normal, but the tall thief has to crabwalk. Like those kind of choices opening up potential avenues of approach and closing others, that I can theorhetically get behind. However, that would also increase the onus on the GM, unless it was made into a part of the mechanics from the get-go. Personally, I think that the tag system from Fate has a lot of potential in that regard, it’s not complex, it’s not 2 pages worth of refresh-my-memory, it’s; Jeff, you have the Tall tag, if you want to enter this corridor, you’ll have to shuffle awkwardly at half speed. Or; GM, since my character is Tall, can I reach onto that ledge? Sure, ok.
Although, my example there was a bit flawed come to think of it, the Mountain was made the Mountain during character creation, but reporter punching Shepard only became that way because of consistently choosing to be mean throughout the game, but we can’t like say; Sorry Jeff, you can’t intimidate the barkeep because up until now you’ve been a swell guy. Or; Jeff, because you’ve been a rude dude with attitude, you can choose to intimidate the barkeep, this exclusive offer is only meant for you, act now or forever hold your peace. The only thing that remotely works that video-gamey way, is reputation.
> Spec lockpicking and you can pick locks, spec interacting, you can schmooze bouncers, and so on. But all that’s doing is opening up possibilities for naked die rolling, and we already talked about how picking which naked die roll to make isn’t gameplay.
But why does that necessarily have to be a naked die roll?
What if we think of the character as a professional doing the actual work, and the player as their manager? A manager doesn’t have to understand the technical details of the job. Their job is to manage costs, risks, and trade-offs.
From that perspective, greater expertise on the part of the character should primarily give the player more control — in other words, a wider range of meaningful trade-offs.
Suppose we’re dealing with lockpicking, and there’s some pressure track visible to the players. The simplest example would just be time: the guards will be making their rounds soon.
A character without particular expertise might have only one basic option:
1. Pick the lock. Fixed DC, costs X amount of time.
But a rogue who is highly skilled at lockpicking is an expert. Yes, they should simply be more likely to succeed, but more importantly, their expertise could give the player a choice of approaches:
1. Careful. Spend more time, but don’t rush. Examine the lock properly, identify its type, choose the right picks, and work slowly and methodically. The DC drops substantially — perhaps even to automatic success, because rogues who specialize in lockpicking actually know how to pick locks.
2. Fast. Spend less time, but accept a higher DC. On a failure you can try again, but two Fast attempts will take more time overall than one Careful attempt would have.
3. Expensive. Use a specialized tool that lets you open the lock both quickly and reliably, but the tool is single-use, valuable, and difficult to replace.
4. Brute-force the mechanism. An expert rogue might recognize that this particular type of lock has a structural weakness at a specific point. They can break it quickly and reliably, but doing so leaves visible damage. If the guards inspect the door closely during their rounds, they may notice the tampering.
5. Any other trade-off the player can come up with, as long as it is fair and has a reasonable narrative explanation.
In that model, the player doesn’t need to know how lockpicking works any more than a manager needs to know how to perform every specialist job performed by the people they manage. The character’s expertise supplies the technical knowledge; the player’s job is to make decisions about time, risk, resources, consequences, and priorities.
And at that point, lockpicking no longer seems like a naked die roll to me. The roll is only resolving one part of a decision the player has already made.
The main issue with D&D like systems is that the bonus from skill far exceeds the bonus (Or difficulty reduction) of a well planned decision. If the rogue has a +15 to sneak, even if the situation makes it really hard and dumb to be sneaky it is probable that being sneaky will still be a more reliable approach then being talky talky with a +0 bonus. This kills gameplay from most situations (challenges)
Taking a detour to deal with character building before finishing the challenge design series makes sense, since players clearly treat building a character as part of the game. Looking forward to the post on making searching and perception actually playable.
Regarding your point as the party acting as a single (optimal) actor, cannot this provide gameplay opportunities ? Since you can design challenges that provide the opportunity to amputate the skill pool by splitting the party or potentially incapacitating a character.
In ways you cannot do with a single character, outside of very specific debuffs I haven’t seen in many games.
Btw love your blog, and as a non-native english speaker I really like the current balance between persona and actual content. The early articles were heavier on tje theatrics and thus a bit harder to read for me.
I liked the distinction between build mastery and path choice. In a small turn-based Roblox RPG I’m documenting, players face a similar tradeoff: class choice shapes available tools, while race and talent rolls are separate and should not be treated as a damage ranking. Separating those layers makes a guide more honest because it explains what changes play and what remains preference. I wrote up a six-class comparison and progression notes here; sharing as the site owner.