Ask Angry: Whatever Are We To Do About the Journey Home?

September 30, 2026

The beacons are lit! Arthur calls for aid!

Well, technically George called for aid, but my Discord members know I obey Arthur, so when he seconded George’s call, I knew I had to drop everything and throw out a little Ask Angry to help them out. After all, I’m currently in catch-up mode, so I might as well put aside what I was polishing for release to write, rewrite, revise, proof, and polish from scratch.

Everyone knows the best way to catch up is to chase every distraction.

Here’s the deal. Angrican George asked a question in my supporter Discord community. Others weighed in. Arthur eventually showed up. Which means I owe George and everyone else an answer. But, honestly, it’s a really good question because it’s a really ugly question, but no one thinks it’s ugly. It’s one of those questions that seems easy to answer if you have a narrow view of what roleplaying games are and what Game Mastering entails. But the more deeply you look at Game Mastering and tabletop roleplaying game and adventure design, the uglier the question gets.

But, really, it’s a good question because the speech I’m about to give about the question is something I know lots of my community members, readers, and Game Masters in general need to hear. Which is why I’m rambling around the non-ugly question that only turns ugly when you know too much and care too much.

You see, it’s easy to make Game Mastering decisions if you think of the game just as a bunch of gamey challenges or just as a world simulation for the players to hex crawl through or just as a stage for the players to play their little stories on. But when you realize how many different elements go into a truly great roleplaying gameplay experience and that you can’t just say, “Well, the game is just this, so I can just do that,” Game Mastering decisions get a lot uglier.

Especially when you really want to get this shit right.

Arthur, George, and probably every one of you reading this right now, you’re all a lot like me. You care. You care a lot. You truly want to deliver the best damned gameplay experience you can in every possible way for your players. You see Game Mastering as a trade to master and a gift you give your players every week.

When you combine an ugly question that’s impossible to answer right with caring way too much about getting things perfect, you end up paralyzed.

The specific thing George struggles with? I do too. I keep changing how I handle it, hoping I can find a good solution. One that satisfies me. One that I believe is letting me provide the best gameplay experience possible for most or all of my players at every table ever. But I also know I probably won’t find one. I’ll only find crappy compromises that require me to leave something on the table. It’s just one of those things where all the answers suck.

That’s why I’m doing this. That’s why I’m dropping everything for this question and this speech. It’s not because I have the answer, but rather because I know there is no good answer, and I still have to pick one. I have to pick my poison and hope it isn’t poisonous enough to take my game away from the greatness I want for it.

That’s the reality of True Game Mastery and True Scenario Designery and True Campaign Managery. Everything is a tradeoff. Everything is about costs and benefits. There are no purely good answers. There are no costs that don’t matter. If you find yourself saying, “I can give this up because, at my table, it doesn’t matter,” you probably didn’t understand the assignment. You’re always compromising something you shouldn’t. That’s because truly great tabletop roleplaying gameplay experiences aren’t narrow. Challenge matters, story matters, agency matters, guidance matters, openness matters, structure matters, pace matters; it all matters, and most things come in opposing pairs. Yeah, players need freedom, or else it isn’t a roleplaying game, but pace and structure are more strongly correlated with engagement and investment, so you have to find a middle ground. Call it closed openness or guided nonlinearity. It doesn’t matter. It’s a compromise between two diametrically opposed forces, both of which can make a game or break it.

The more you know and the more you care, the more screwed you feel.

Except that’s not true either. That’s the other reason I want to give this speech. Because I know George needs it, and I can think of a handful of others, by name, who need to hear it again, and probably lots of you need it too.

Yes, it all matters, and if you care, it matters a lot. But it also doesn’t matter that much. Gameplay experiences are very complex, holistic, emergent things. You don’t have to get every part exactly right. You just have to get enough right enough. You can actually get a lot wrong and still get a good gameplay experience.

But here’s the kicker…

There’s an aspect of all this crap that pushes every good game toward greatness. It’s a spice that makes even an okay game good and a good game great. You’re probably adding it without realizing it. The Game Master’s energy, their passion and drive and genuine care, your passion and drive and genuine care, those bleed into the game without you realizing it, and they matter a lot.

Unless you get in your own way. And lots of Game Masters do. See, you have to trust that that’s how it works. Not just the part about passion, but also the part about getting enough things right enough. Most Game Masters don’t. They don’t trust themselves to make good enough decisions. They don’t trust the game to just turn out okay.

Not too long ago, the feedback discussion broke out in my Discord community for the umpteen billionth time. You know what I mean, right? Game Masters are always trying to interrogate their players: what’s good, what’s bad, are you having fun, what would be more fun, what isn’t fun, should I do more of this, should I do less of that, how important is exploration to you on a scale from one to ten, does this screen make me look fat, would you prefer more time in town, where are your rebel friends now, and so on, and cetera, and nauseum.

You want my advice when it comes to feedback: just fucking stop it. Stop expecting it, stop seeking it, stop thinking it’s worth a single, solitary crap. I know that sounds crazy. Every time I say that, mouthbreathing asshats appear to scream about how I’m wrong and then tell everyone how they’ve discovered the precise end-of-session routine to get perfect feedback that has made their game so much better for their players. But experiments don’t work without control groups, and I’m the control group. I gave up on feedback years ago, and yet I somehow manage to run the best roleplaying gameplay experiences ever and make them better every year. Do you know how I end my sessions: “Thanks for playing, guys; hope you all had fun; by the way, nice job on that squid encounter.”

That’s it. Very, very occasionally, I will ask a player an open question because I notice something seems off or because I did something experimental and it didn’t feel like it landed well. I don’t do surveys, and I don’t interrogate. I just say, “You seemed a little checked out; is everything okay?” Or, “I was doing my narration a little differently tonight. Did you notice? Did it feel different?”

Now, my players do meet my “I hope you had fun tonight,” with specific feedback pretty often. My players like to tell me what, specifically, was fun, and it can turn into a very nice little ego stroking, but I ain’t doing it for feedback. I say that because it’s true. I genuinely end every game session hoping I gave my players a good time. And if all they say is, “Yeah, it was fun,” I’m happy.

That has to be enough for you. In fact, wanting more can be really bad for you. There’s this adage in playtesting and quality assurance: players are good at knowing whether they’re happy, bad at explaining why, and terrible at predicting what would make them happier. Player feedback is a great way to find out there’s a problem, but it’s a terrible diagnostic tool and the worst planning tool. You can’t trust any answer beyond a happy face or frowny face. And you shouldn’t have to ask for that.

Being a great Game Master is a lot like being a great parent. You can’t make every right choice. Most of the time, there isn’t even a right choice. Most choices are between different flavors of shit. All you can do is make the best choice your limited judgment allows and hope you make enough good enough calls. If your game succeeds, you’ll never know if it’s because of your choices or despite them. If it fails, you’ll never know whether you could have done something to prevent it or whether it was beyond your control. The fact that your game is still running today and your players showed up again has to be enough because it’s all you can hope for.

So, with all of that said…

Angrican George asked a question, and I want to explain why it’s a shitty question with only shitty answers, and that all anyone can do is pick a shitty answer and hope it’s not the thing that ruins your game. Which it won’t. Because it’s really hard for a passionate, caring Game Master to ruin a game just by handling the ends of adventures less than perfectly.

Whatever Are We To Do About the Journey Home?

George wanted to know about the return trip from the adventure site because he’s realized, like many of us do, that it’s one of the ugliest parts of the whole adventure design thing. Unless, of course, you’re narrow-minded about what the gameplay experience entails or you just don’t care. Seriously, anyone who offers an easy answer to this question is not to be trusted. They don’t understand the assignment. You can only trust people who start their answer with, “Yeah, that’s an ugly question. All I can do is tell you what I do, but I know it sucks…”

Let me clarify what we’re talking about a little so we can look at the problem…

The players’ characters have set out from a safe location, like town, and trekked their way to an adventure site, like a dungeon. There, they’ve had a grand adventure, beaten a boss monster, and rescued Princess MacGuffin. Now, they are leaving the dungeon, flush with cash, Scottish Highlander nobility cheerfully following, and they have to get home.

Now what?

What makes this question ugly is that, from a gameplay standpoint, the game is over, and from a narrative standpoint, the game has reached a dramatic conclusion, but procedurally and fantastically, there’s still stuff to do.

In gameplay design, the rule is that, once the primary challenge has been overcome, the players should claim the goal, and then the game should quickly end. You can see most clearly what it feels like to ignore that rule in those combats that end up in a mop up phase. The biggest threat is dead, the heroes are still fighting strong, but there are all these half-dead minions ineffectually running around, and the players have to chase them down and whittle all their hit points to zero. It’s boring because there’s no uncertainty left in the gameplay. The gameplay tension is resolved. The outcome is known. Unless they really fuck up bad, the players can’t really change the outcome. They just have to complete the chore of actually winning.

You can’t, by the way, solve this with a simple trick of wording. You can’t just say, “Well, the goal is to get Princess MacGuffin safely home so, technically, until she’s sipping mead with Laird MacGuffin in her dad’s timber hall, the uncertainty still exists.” That’s only true if there’s a good reason to think a significant threat might snatch victory away from the heroes. And before you ask, the answer is no; you can’t just solve this with some highwaymen attacking on the way home. You can’t follow, “Slay the dragon and save Princess MacGuffin,” with “Oh no! Several unwashed bandits!” The major challenge was the dragon. Princess MacGuffin, true to her namesake, was the goal, and lest you think I’m being sexist, you should know every member of the McGuffin line, male and female alike, was kidnapped at least three times in their lives. Actually, Princess MacGuffin is running well above average. This was her first kidnapping, and she comes of age next year.

Sorry…

The major challenge was the dragon, and Princess MacGuffin was the goal. Once the dragon’s dead and the Princess is with the heroes, anything you throw at them is just minion mop-up bullshit.

Meanwhile, the basic rule of drama is that, after the rising action hits a climax, the story is effectively over, so resolve it, denouement it, and move on. That’s why Peter Jackson was right to cut out that scouring of the Shire crap, but then ruined it by giving the movie seven frigging endings.

Rage-baiting the Tolkienistas aside, there’s a word for trying to raise the tension again after the climax has played out. That word is anticlimax. Anticlimaxes are draining, boring, and sap all the goodwill from the climax that came before them. Once Smauglethrax is dead and Princess MacGuffin is saved, get Han and Luke to the medal ceremony because the story is over.

But roleplaying games need consistency and verisimilitude. There’s a reality to the fictional world you just can’t break. Why? Because roleplaying is literally the act of imagining that you are your character and the situation they are facing is real. The gameplay has to conform to the reality of the world. If it doesn’t, you break the willing suspension of disbelief, and then the players can’t care about the world like a real place anymore.

If the journey out was dangerous, why would the journey home be any less dangerous? Did the wilderness suddenly become safe and non-hostile and impossible to get lost in just because you won? I mean, you might argue that killing the dragon might impact the ecology of the region, but that’s an adventure-specific contrivance. The issue remains that the characters are three days from home and there’s dangerous terrain on the way that they might get attacked in, lost in, or starve in. The journey home has to be the same as the journey out.

Now, we could say all this maps to the elements of gameplay defined in some gamer motivation model or another. For example, in my favorite model, the MDA model, I’d say the problem is about the conflicting needs of Challenge, Narrative, and Fantasy, and you, the Game Master as game designer, are stuck having to break one of those. But it’s not even as clean as that. The procedural issue isn’t just about making the world real. There’s more to it.

If you run the wilderness as gameplay, then it presents a challenge, right? There are risks to trekking into the wilds. There are encounters, complications, obstacles, and resource costs to contend with. If those challenges change depending on which direction the players are walking, you’re putting the players in a bad place.

Suppose you do the hand-wavy narrative, “… and then you headed home,” thing. Suppose you don’t calculate speed or settle navigation or compute resources consumed. Now it’s time for the players to plan their next expedition. Should they buy enough food to get there and back again, or do they only need enough food for the journey out because getting back is going to get handwaved?

Note, by the way, that this ain’t about my fear of players exploiting the game. I don’t worry about that. Which is another reason people think I’m crazy. What I do worry about, though, is putting my players in the uncomfortable position of having to deliberately choose not to cheat. If you, as a normal, reasonable, innocent player, notice that I never ask you to count food on the return trip, you now have to decide whether you should buy the extra food anyway just to be honest. You know I’m skipping the trip home to streamline, but the fair assumption is that your character needs the food anyway, so shouldn’t you just mark off the money and maybe even mark off the food? I don’t want my players weighing that kind of crap in their heads, but ever.

Don’t get too hung up on this as being about food consumption, by the way. This is about everything. Anything. Should the players hold back healing resources for the journey home? Should they slow down and carefully blaze a trail on their way to the dungeon so they don’t get lost coming home? Should they bring extra supplies for the prisoner they’re planning to rescue? Should they plan a longer, but easier route home to make it easier on the prisoner? There are a thousand issues that might arise when you start hand-waving gameplay procedure.

See how this isn’t as clean anymore as “Challenge plus Narrative beats Fantasy, so Fast Travel?” Challenge is actually straddling the fence. Ignoring the trip home is leaving some gameplay challenge on the table. Or it could potentially leave a potential challenge on the table in a certain adventure. Escorting Princess MacGuffin is a fair gameplay challenge, after all. It’s an escort quest. Is that worth playing out at least this time? Is it enough of a gameplay challenge to justify an anticlimax?

Speaking of anticlimax, or rather, postclimax, consider how it might feel to fail in the postclimax. Say your players survive the trek, clear the dungeon, slay the dragon, rescue Princess MacGuffin, and then, on the way home, she’s lost crossing a river or dies of dysentery. That is a completely valid outcome of a fair challenge, but do you really want that to be a way this adventure might end? It’s kind of dickish to ask your players to kill a dragon and then, instead of a victory party, let them tell the questgiver how their daughter shit herself to death on the way home because the rations had gone bad. You see what I mean, right? How would you feel at the end of that session? Not great, right? I know I wouldn’t. You know how I know that? I know that because I’ve done that. Not quite literally that, but I’ve taken my players’ amazing victory away with a really horrible postclimax failure. I did not end that session with my customary, “Thanks for playing; hope y’all had fun.”

The trek home is a lot like character death. Not doing it sucks, but doing it also sucks. No matter what, it sucks. Any Game Master, by the way, that says character death is unambiguously good and doesn’t suck is an asshole. Character death is, at best, a necessary evil, and I’m not even convinced it’s actually necessary. If you think otherwise, you’re bad, and you’re wrong, and you should feel bad.

So whatever should you do with the trek home? Whatever do I do? I don’t know… I just kind of do it. I hold my nose and I… remember my promise to my brand manager about casually making horrible, inappropriate remarks. I hold my nose, and I just get through it.

I usually play out the trek home, but I’m aware the whole time that it sucks, so I don’t linger on it. I pace it well. I condense it as much as I can, but I don’t actually skip the rules and procedures. I accept something terrible might happen. If I can make a challenge of it, like with escorting Princess MacGuffin, I do that, but I don’t forget it’s a postclimax challenge, so I don’t make a big thing of it, and I keep the difficulty on the easier side. If I can use the trek home to do some falling action denouement crap, I’ll do that. If Complications arise, I’ll hedge away from involved encounters and favor smaller things. I don’t want to ever say, “Sure, you beat the dragon, but can you handle three forest spiders!? Aaaah!” Of course, if the party’s escorting Princess MacGuffin or they’re laboring with a hard-to-transport prize or someone’s gravely injured or cursed, three forest spiders might be worth a fight, but it’s still a postclimax.

Really, it’s not so much a standard approach to the trek home as a grudging compromise. I know I can’t skip the procedure because of my philosophy toward roleplaying games and because I want wilderness treks to matter, so I can’t make them only matter conditionally. But I also know they stink. Really, the best analogy I can think of is what I already said: “I hold my nose and I get through them as quickly as I can.”

Is that the best answer? Yeah, I think so, but best doesn’t mean good when all the answers are shit. Fortunately, I run a good game, so my players have never even seemed to notice the few minutes of stinky ending at the end of every expedition.

The problem isn’t the trek; the problem is that I’m too smart and I care too much.


[jetpack_subscription_form]

29 thoughts on “Ask Angry: Whatever Are We To Do About the Journey Home?”

  1. One “solution” I’ve used is to end the session when the dragon is dead and Princess McGuffin rescued.

    They have their victory, they can savor it for a week, and then the next session starts and the first thing is the journey back, and the second half is (hopefully) town action + setup for the next adventure. That way the journey back has some separation from the victory and is a separate (escort) mini-quest.

    I’m not great on town actions so the timing rarely works perfectly, the return mini-quest shouldn’t fill a full session in most cases. And it also typically means starting the next session with half the players talking about what they’re doing in town or with the reward till I point out three or four times that they are nowhere near the town and need to get there through all that dangerous wilderness (admittedly, the 11 year old is the one who needs more than one reminder on this).

    • Interesting, that’s exactly what I was thinking. The big problem with the Scouring of the Shire (which is THE BEST PART OF THE LORD OF THE RINGS, and I don’t know if I’m more furious that Jackson cut it from the films or that he and Angry are absolutely correct that it needed to be cut) is that it’s really a separate story. It doesn’t contribute anything to the drama of the Ring Quest, but it has drama in its own right; to make it fun and interesting, it needs to be completely separated so it’s not an anticlimax. So what I’m saying is that Jackson needs to film a fourth LotR film and, no, never mind, Saruman is already dead (in the film and in real life, RIP Sir Christopher), so everything is just doomed to kind of suck. Ah well.

      • That is the fairest, best take I have ever heard from anyone rising to my bait with bait of thier own, and I honestly agree with you. I would even shake your hand if I ever met you at a convention. Three pumps; no tongue. If it had been a short story or even an appendix story, it would have been amazing. Thematically, it was definitely a story worth telling. But crammed between the resolution and the denouement, it raised the spoilers at a time when the plane was already too low.

        • In a book it is defensible, or at least manageable, in the service of the thematic points he’s trying to make and the kind of story he wants to tell about the heroes. You can get away with that since it’s not usually a one-sitting kind of affair and making your plot arc weaker in the service of your themes is a tradeoff you can make your readers put up with. The denouement is like 1/3rd of the page count of RotK anyhow.

          The people who think it should have gone into the movie are crazy, film has different rules, you can’t be doing that shit in a film.

  2. My immediate thought is that part of the issue is the binary nature of “finished”.

    Either the princess is rescued, or she isn’t. So any obstacles on the way home completely negate your victory if failed.

    If, however, there was some granuality to it – there’s a curse only she can break, and the longer it takes or the more injured she is the fewer curses she can break – then it becomes not just, “you won!”, but how well you won.

    Obviously that’s not always possible, and you’d want to make sure the players knew ahead of time this was going to be the case, but for the important endings it might help.

  3. Can this be partially handled by explaining why the return journey is simpler or rolling the return journey into the quest itself?

    Simpler: Your dragon changing the ecology is one example, another might be that the MacGuffin PCs find dispels the curse over the land, etc. There are many reasons like this.
    Part of the Quest: You need to return the MacGuffin to the town within X days to prevent Y (invasion, blood rite, etc.), such that the entire time PCs are in the climax battle they know they still need to race the clock to get home, hopefully maintaining tension.

    • Video games do this fairly often. You beat the big bad, the curse is lifted, all the nasty monsters turn back into townspeople, the mysterious confounding fog lifts, the end of your dungeon has a shortcut back home, etc.

      It’s a bit cliché (and awkward if you killed a bunch of the monsters…) but it’s being done for the very good reasons angry just outlined.

    • Taking the idea of “wilderness as a dungeon,” this is the equivalent of the droppable ladder or door you can only open from the far side–a way to make a shortcut for the return trip.

      You could give the princess/MacGuffin some kind of magic power that makes the return trip easier… put the dungeon at the mouth of a fast-flowing river so the party can easily take a boat back down… have friendly giant eagles show up as soon as you defeat the dragon (they couldn’t some sooner because the dragon would have roasted them, obviously)…

  4. My players and I don’t really have the patience for or interest in wilderness wackiness. We prefer to get right to the story, follow the story and only the story, then get right back to home base as fast as possible to get setup for the next story. But I know other groups and GMs feel differently. I will describe the journey there and back again with some color narrative about how they dodged a couple airship patrols from evil island nation army, saw a pair of wild griffins in the distance that decided the PC’s airship was too big to prey on, ran across some forest blood monkeys trying to throw rocks and feces at them as they flew by overhead, and what is that really weird and ominous weather we see to the North – what could that be about (i.e. foreshadowing future story). Of course, if the players decide they want to engage with something during travel, I will halt the color narrative and let them do it. But like I said, they’re not usually interested in non-story elements.

    As far as the Scouring of the Shire, I always dreaded when I got to that part of the book. I knew it was unnecessary and tedious, but I felt an obligation to the great and powerful Tolkien – and to Frodo – to read it, so I always did, gritting my teeth with every page. I figured it built character. I was glad when Jackson left it out of the movie.

  5. Great advice and thank you.

    I am slightly concerned (meaning I found myself laughing) that you end with “Thanks for playing, guys; hope you all had fun; by the way, nice job on that squid encounter.”

    Like squid fetish that there is one in every session or a reference to the last time they actually did well (implication it wasn’t this session)?

    The fun with written language… and to be clear: yes I know better.

  6. I think one solution is to build an easy return home into the adventure itself. In the scenario given, I would have it that the main dangers on the way are dragon cultists trying to stop the party. I would also have it that Princess McGuffin’s father/mother/protector has called for a small army to rescue her but they will take a few days to arrive, so by the time the party emerge from the dragon’s lair with the princess there is an escort to take them back.

    It’s all about expanding the world-building a little to add some depth while allowing some subtle deus-ex-machina.

  7. Great article, thank you for it.
    I agree that it’s ugly. I agree that it’s a hard and difficult question to do either way.
    Counterpoint, I never narrate the journey home. I know that sounds like a narrative thing, like skipping to the “happily ever after.” But I have a counter argument for that. I don’t know a single video game that doesn’t include a shortcut or fast travel option once you have beaten a boss or hard encounter (unless it’s for a very good reason; eg: anticlimax or foreshadowing.) Like… the only exception I can think of is Midna’s Lament in Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess, and that to me, while a total anti-climax, is something worth playing. I think the gameplay is worth exploring both from a narrative and gameplay perspective, and it would be lost if the player instantly warped back to Princess Zelda. So I agree that there must be exceptions to my own personal rule of “fast travel after every boss.”
    I also understand your argument for rations and the journey home, and dysentery. I just personally have no interest in playing that kind of game with my players.
    If you want that game, go for it, I am not going to say that it doesn’t sound fun or that your players won’t find it fun. I just don’t personally find it fun, so thus, I’m inclined to not include it.

    But honestly, this talk does make me feel like I should probably make fast travel a gameplay setpiece, rather than just a narrative “and then they went home.” It probably wouldn’t hurt my games at all if I included a warp stone that only activates once you have the boss’ heart or something. It sounds like a fun idea, that will definitely have narrative implications like: “What if someone steals the stone?” “What if the players kill a creature that they think is the boss, but actually isn’t?” and “What if they decide to not kill the boss?” I know the answer is “well, they won’t be able to use it, and they’ll have to figure it out.” But it feels a lot more interesting that way rather than relying on my own personal, “I feel like fast travel is better for a gameplay and narrative perspective.”

  8. Saving enough resources for the trip back is part of the outbound trip’s challenge. I theorize that the journey back should be abstracted as some kind of fast-travel check. If the party could take 10 to pass then mark off enough resources for the trip and return to town by cinematic hand wave, else it is a substantial enough challenge to warrant playing out the adventure next session.

    One session was the Iliad and the next will be the Odyssey, or just fast travel home if you can “afford” to.

  9. I guess I make sure the players have enough rations for the return journey before they set out. But that only deals with a small bit of the issue.

    I’ve often felt there’s a case for a “quick resolution” mechanic along the lines of “everyone roll a DC20 against your main stat; for every 5 you fail by, over the 3 day return journey the party loses 25Gp of resources, which you replace as soon as you reach town.” I don’t like that precisely, but something that simple. Equipment is damaged, etc.

    Something that provides a mechanic for “there were obstacles you overcame, but there was a cost”.

    And with the risk/cost adjusted based on the route, and with the option for spending longer-term resources (single-use scroll, etc) to reduce the risks.

  10. I have hand waived the trip home about 50% of the time. The trip itself is more often about experiencing the world than the obstacle challenges themselves, and the trip home can often feel redundant if an alternate path is not chosen. I consider that most challenges/monsters on the route to the dragon have been removed (and new monsters have not yet moved in) or can be navigated around as before. Moreover, I might have news travel faster than the party. Most intelligent enemies will believe they can’t win a fight against a party that slew a dragon assuming (the party does not look too injured because they are fit to travel), and even less intelligent monsters would not choose to attack the party carrying a fresh dragon head before them. Thus, the only monsters faced would likely be the giant spiders you mentioned in your article (and even a spider is smart enough to free a bee from its web), which hopefully are few. So the return trip is mostly about tying up loose ends with NPCs they met along the way, like returning a magic item that aided them in fighting the dragon or returning with an item/information found in the dragon lair that was promised in exchange for information to help defeat the dragon.

  11. Yes, those back trips are a stinky problem. I’ve always felt they are. I usually, if not always, disregarded any advice from an adventure or a rulebook to just skip to the ending cutscene.

    Sometimes it dragged out to a boring anticlimax. Other times, though, it made the victory an equivalent of rescuing the Princess McGuffin from the Darth Bowser’s interrogation cell.

    Now, thanks to reading this feature, not only I will know what does stink so much – I’ll be evaluating and second-guessing every choice on the road to the Rebel Castle. But sarcasm aside, I think being conscious about the choice here is well worth it. Postclimax traps are nasty little suckers. I’ll have that in mind especially while designing any new scenario.

  12. Also *gulps the hook*: LotR was made in a different convention of literary work. Like, you know, a myth or a saga by some older standards.

    SPOILER ALERT

    By far the oldest example of such an anticlimactic ending closes the Poem of Gilgamesh. Dude defied the most vengeful of the gods, fought his way through the deadly gates of the paradise, and passed several tests there. Finally, he gets the Herb of Life Eternal as his prize, and on his way home… a snake jumps out of the water, grabbing the Herb do the bottom of the sea – all in like 4 or 5 lines, just a paragraph before the end credits. Beowulf or the King Arthur’s stories follow similar way.

    I’m not saying that this kind of stuff is a perfect narrative device for every story. It’s just that a Hero’s Journey has to end by bringing the Supernatural back home, you know.

    All who are heroes do not epilogue,
    not all those who slay dragons walk home.
    Some say the climax should be a releaser,
    others read to process quite slow.

  13. I think the biggest problem lies with medieval fantasy specifically, because all they really had were wagons, wagons without suspension mind, and horses, also without suspension. But if it were any other setting you could have a blackhawk swoop in to pick them up, or they catch the tube home while scattering, or a cool motorcycle chase or something.

    Not to say that the long trek home wouldn’t ever happen in one of those settings, but it sure becomes easier to skip it in a conveniently believable manner, oh you went trekking in the Amazon or the Andes, well there just so happens to be a hiker here with a 4X4, or a drug baron’s growing operation, also with 4X4s. Just thinking about the Andes immediately makes me go: skiing while escaping an avalanche, there are just so many more options.

    But medieval times, no trade route, no business for carts to go there, you’re probably walking. And even if you can afford a mount, for long range travel they aren’t much faster than walking, plus now you gotta secure feed and quite a lot of water for them as well.

    • You could give them a boat or a magical portal I suppose. But the shortcuts can feel contrived if you’re doing it every time.

      • It’s easy to teleport to a permanent teleportation circle in a known safe location. Kind of falls under the same category of mundane challenges which can be skipped with magic, like the Bag of Holding for encumbrance.

        Scroll of Town Portal. Escape rope. Homeward bone. Once there’s no forward progress left to lose since you’ve reached the end, then save and quit.

      • Boats are interesting in that either the trip there or the return is going to be upstreams (unless it’s across a lake), depending on where the mission/adventure site is located, which gives a bit of a difference in the two trips. But unless the site is located right at the water, there’s bound to be some walking involved there too.

        I didn’t include any magical means since that depends on the setting, something like a flying ship is more magitech than medieval, for instance. Magic portals are awfully convenient devices in that you could only have it functioning one-way if you want, or occasionally mis-fire and send them off to somewhere they didn’t intend to go, or as more of an unlockable late game travel method when you’ve done the whole walking there and back to death, but at that point its introduction will obviously change the whole setting and rock the foundations of almost every major power. Trade especially will be impacted. So in terms of including magic, if you want to get really technical, even something like a bookshelf with books makes it so you’re no longer in a medieval setting. Probably something like potatoes as well because of the ease of calories, but eh.

        Yes, and that’s what I’ve landed at, that there’s just such a comparatively smaller pool of available choices to change things up when it comes to medieval fantasy, unless you go hogwild with magic and make it magitech. Personally I’m always tempted to add something like trains for that ease of convenience (since the steam engine predates the medieval era) but their very existence change so much, and I’d prefer not to have rails running across the landscape, although at that point, is it even a train anymore… I think the wheel of time did a cool variant also with the Ways from the Ogiers’ steddings, although to be quite fair, those were just walking in a different location, but they did speed up travel at a cost.

  14. i just finished an adventure today and I definitely felt this, saying “great job guys so and so congratulates and rewards you la dee dah now lets pick up and go home” somehow felt like the victory was lessened.

  15. I think that this really depends on where you are in the campaign. If there’s going to be an adventure after this, then the trip home is both forward- and backward-looking. Douglas Lampert’s idea of ending the session on the victory works well in that case. If it’s the end of the campaign I think you’re way better off having characters ride off into the sunset/epilogue as soon as the big bad is defeated. If you have seasons to a campaign and you’re finishing up a big arc, that’s the hardest call, but then either option seems justifiable.

  16. I think the most important take away I have after reading this, is that the return journey can’t be ignored. If you want to skip it, you should think of that while designing the adventure and build in things that will allow you to skip it without breaking verisimilitude. If you want to play it out, bake that in from the start in order to mitigate any downsides from the potentially “less exciting” challenges that come up. If you are thinking about it and trying to make it fun/not suck, it’s bound to come through to your players.

  17. First it occurs to me that asking for feedback might be one of those things like fudging dice rolls that isn’t a healthy ongoing practice but it’s probably a necessary stage in honing the craft: It’s a canon event, you just gotta let it happen.

    A guy named Ron Edwards wrote some really thought provoking articles on this problem, but he didn’t really come to any deeper answer: Basically he concluded you just had to take a *Motivation Unter Alles* approach and pick the thing it bothered you least to sacrifice, and try to be upfront and consistent that you would be breaking your tradeoffs the same way most of the time.

    • There’s definitely better and worse ways of doing it. Constructive criticism is likely what we’d have the most potential use for, but at the same time some people just want to have their ego stroked, and the players are aware of that fact as well, and they don’t want to be punished for speaking up. Criticism in general is socially frowned upon and they’re probably even more unlikely to express negativity if they’re feeling grateful, so it’s better not to ask them as a group, but at the same time that means that you’re taking time from them that isn’t game-time, and that’s always iffy. Plus this also flies in the face of the fact that preferably you’d want to ask them directly when their impressions are fresh, or do you? Would it be better to let them digest it first? Maybe, although probably not too long.

      Not to mention that they might not be able to identify what it is that’s not sitting quite right with them, or worse they think it’s one thing but it’s actually another. So yeah, careful wording, careful timing and don’t take what they say as gospel.

  18. There was a small talk about LOTR earlier, I went through it 2 times and could never manage the part after the …main goal is achieved. It’s all songs! I skilled through it trying to find some text and there was barely any, and it felt just as sloppy in the movie, I think my mind has shut it out, or maybe I didn’t Watch the movie, I don’t remember.
    Back to the title my way that doesn’t suck too much is the same that has been used in successful séries for years: The art of the cliffhanger. Dragon is defeated, they go for princess mcguffin but, she isn’t in her cell, instead there’s a letter with a mystery to solve Tada, see you next session ! Or they go out with princess mcguffin but there’s a while army sieging the castle now and they don’t look friendly. Or whatever just don’t stop until the end if the season(arc or even campaign). Is it just postponing the pain? Not really, they always hold their breath wondering what’s gonna happen again and when finally nothing does and I start narrating what happens to every character I can hear the sighs of relief. So here’s a new tech for your arsenal if you didn’t have it yet.

Comments are closed.